The same general class of incidents occur in numerous sports, though likely none more prominent than on the soccer field. To argue that a referee should make the game less fair is to fail to understand the role of the referee in the first place.Īt this point, we can promote two possible prescriptions for action. At the least, when the ball goes out of bounds off the hand of a player, she should not actively advocate as if it didn’t in attempt to deceive the referee. In a stronger version, the athlete would actually motion that the ball had, in fact, gone off her hand. Given this obvious truth, then, the addition of a referee should make the game more fair and not less. Ethicists and sporting enthusiasts alike agree on the ethics of this simplistic case. Clearly, that player should admit to the transgression and award the other player the ball the player should not behave as though it didn’t touch his hand. What an odd moment it would be for the two of them if he did. To simplify, imagine two people playing 1-on-1 basketball. The ball goes off the fingertips of one player unbeknown to the other. One player is guilty of deceiving the referee (and, additionally, deceiving his opponent). And many find no ethical concern with it: deceiving the referee, they argue, is just part of the game. ![]() It should be of no surprise that this sort of deception occurs from the top down. Watch any competitive basketball game and you’re bound to see the following incident on repeated occasions: the ball goes out of bounds and two opposing players nearest the ball point fervently in opposite directions signaling that it’s their respective team’s ball. He applauded the tactic though did express some concern, primarily regarding Kidd’s execution of the move, as though he’d performed a fundamental basketball maneuver poorly: Don’t let your elbow flare out when shooting a jump shot and don’t “over-act” when you’re spilling liquid on the court for a timeout. The most amazing, in that disheartening sort of way, coming from ex-NBA coach, Kevin Loughery. 1 Commentary ensued throughout the sporting world regarding the virtue of this move. ![]() Here’s the brief recap: NBA coach Jason Kidd instructed a player to bump into him so that he could “accidentally” spill his drink on the court, causing the referee to award a much-needed timeout. ![]() Last week’s “Spillgate 2013” provides a great springboard for the follow-up to Part I of this blog.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |